
SWELLENDAM – There was a time, not so long ago, when Swellendam Municipality was rather chuffed with itself.
In 2025, it celebrated being ranked second best in South Africa, receiving national recognition at the inaugural Municipal Performance Awards hosted by the South African Property Owners Association (SAPOA), Ratings Afrika and the Banking Association of South Africa.
The ranking came from Ratings Afrika, an independent governance ratings agency whose Municipal Financial Sustainability Index (MFSI) assessed the financial health of municipalities.
Swellendam scored 73 out of 100. Only Saldanha Bay and Swartland, which shared first place, scored higher.
News62 reported on the achievement at the time. It was a result worth celebrating, but a year later, the picture looks rather different.
In its latest assessment, based on municipal financial results for the year ending June 2025, Swellendam does not feature among the country’s five leading municipalities.
Those five, as pointed out in a recent column by Western Cape Premier Alan Winde, were Drakenstein, Hessequa, Overstrand, Saldanha Bay and Swartland. All were in the Western Cape.
The exact new score and national ranking for Swellendam have not been established.
News62 reached out to Leon Claassen, Managing Executive and Lead Analyst at Ratings Afrika, to establish where Swellendam currently ranks.
Claassen confirmed receipt of our questions, but has yet to provide any indication of the municipality’s latest position.
Regardless of the new rating on the national table, the municipality’s absence from the top five was a considerable change from the recognition it had proudly received the previous year.
One of the first challenges the newly elected council therefore faces will be to ensure that the municipality returns to the top five.
And that brings us to Premier Winde.
Winde’s Western Cape Success Story
In an article published by the Daily Maverick, Winde highlighted the five top-rated municipalities and praised the province’s record of stable leadership and good governance.
His message was clear: the Western Cape had municipalities that were getting things right.
Fair enough. The province had reason to celebrate those results, but Swellendam is no longer on that list.
To this point, former Swellendam Mayor Nicholas Myburgh lauded Swellendam for its great financial stability during the run-up to the local elections.
Yet it would be interesting to find out what the response of the soon-to-be sworn-in council will be to the fact that the municipality moved from a R16 million operating surplus in 2023/24 to a R20.8 million operating deficit in 2024/25, despite increasing its operating revenue by more than R100 million.
The irony was difficult to miss. The municipality had previously been happy to put its second-place ranking on display. Now, with the latest Ratings Afrika results, residents are entitled to ask what had changed.
Winde’s praise of the province’s top performers only made that question more relevant.
After all, a good provincial reputation does not automatically make every municipality a good one, and a trophy from last year does not pay this year’s bills.
The R326.6 million question
The latest rankings were not the only figures facing the new council.
National Treasury figures showed that Swellendam reported approximately R193.2 million in irregular expenditure over five financial years, from 2019/20 to 2023/24.
The figures were:
- 2019/20: R20.2 million
- 2020/21: R19.8 million
- 2021/22: R54.6 million
- 2022/23: R35.1 million
- 2023/24: R63.5 million
But the 2024/25 figures add another significant amount to that picture.
The municipality reported a further R133.36 million in irregular expenditure for the year ending June 2025. That takes the total reported irregular expenditure across the six financial years to approximately R326.6 million.
The 2024/25 figures also listed R39.346 million in unauthorised expenditure and R3,000 in fruitless and wasteful expenditure. These are separate categories and should not be confused with irregular expenditure.
It is, however, important to note that irregular expenditure does not automatically mean money was stolen or that the full amount was lost.
It means expenditure did not comply with the required laws or procedures, and this is where ongoing investigations into various aspects of the municipality’s day-to-day functions need to be assessed.
R326.6 million over a six-year period is not pocket change. It is still public money and the taxpayers who foot the bill deserve to know how it was dealt with.
It would also serve the community to know whether the newly elected councillors understand the difference between Irregular Expenditure, Unauthorised Expenditure and Fruitless and Wasteful Expenditure.
While the municipality received a clean audit for 2024/25 it does not mean that the reported irregular expenditure simply disappears or that every question about it has been answered.
Residents should be told what makes up the latest R133.36 million, what investigations have established and what steps have been taken to deal with the expenditure.
Almost R1 million in forensic investigations, fruitless and wasteful or just irregular?
In recent years the municipality commissioned two external forensic investigations, by Nexus Forensic Services and Mubesko Africa.
Their combined documented appointment value was R911,512.11.
Note: For the purpose of this article we have not included the recent work that was conducted by Morar Incorporated, which is estimated to be an additional R300k.
The Nexus and Mubesko reports were completed and presented to Council, but presenting a report is not the same as acting on it.
Almost R1-million was committed to these investigations and residents are entitled to know whether the findings led to disciplinary action, recovery of money or meaningful consequences for anyone found responsible.
If the investigations led nowhere, taxpayers deserve to know why. If action was taken, the new council should make that clear.
And there is another development.
In June 2026, the municipality advertised a further investigation under tender number SMQ77-25-26, titled “Provision of Financial Misconduct Investigating Services”. The tender closed on June 19.
Three bids were recorded, with prices ranging from R253,000 to R332,000. However, News62 has not been able to establish a publicly disclosed final award value or identify the successful service provider from the municipal records reviewed.
So, while questions remain about what happened to the recommendations of the previous investigations, another investigation has been put out to tender.
Residents are entitled to ask what this latest investigation is intended to establish, why it is necessary and what has happened to the findings of the work already commissioned.
The election is over. Now earn your keep.
Some councillors will return, while others will enter the council chamber for the first time, but none of them inherited a free pass.
There will be explanations and political finger-pointing. Fortunately, the bulk of the previous administration will be in council and will have questions to answer.
As they prepare for what is likely to be a turbulent term, the new council should know that they owe residents clear answers:
- What came of the Nexus and Mubesko recommendations?
- With close to R1-million spent on those investigations, what financial losses, if any, were identified, and how much of that money has been recovered?
- Was disciplinary action taken and was any money recovered?
- If no disciplinary action was taken and further findings relating to these reports come to light, will those councillors returning to council, who allegedly voted against implementing the recommendations, explain their decisions and accept political responsibility?
- What does the latest R133.36 million in reported irregular expenditure consist of?
- What is the purpose of the further financial misconduct investigation advertised in June 2026, and what happened to the recommendations of the previous investigations?
- What concrete steps will be taken to improve the municipality’s financial position?
- Again, will this council take accountability for its actions?
Winde celebrated the Western Cape’s top performers. Swellendam had once been among them. The latest figures told a different story.
Residents have heard enough promises. They deserve answers, transparency and results, regardless of who will be wearing the mayoral chain.




